An analysis of the charges against socrates brought upon him by a man meletus

The cocktail party socrates questions agathon's speech, suggesting that agathon has spoken about the object of love, rather than love itself to correct him, socrates relates what he was once told by a wise woman named diotima. The reason for this is so that the man, meletus, who feels that he is bring justified charges against socrates to the gods, because he is bringing charges against his father of murder meletus feels that socrates is being impiety or impious to his father in not showing him respect for what he has done. 24b - 28a summary socrates now turns from his old accusers to his new ones, those who have brought him to trial socrates reminds the court that they accuse him of corrupting the minds of the young and of believing in supernatural phenomena of his own invention rather than in the gods of the state. In the apology, socrates says this about his charges (i am using the translation from the perseus project): now so far as the accusations are concerned which my first accusers made against me [referring to rumor, calumny, and public opinion], this is a sufficient defence before you but against meletus, the good and patriotic, as he says, and.

The apology by socrates is a speech which he gave during his unsuccessful defense against the charges of corrupting the youths and being atheist, in addition to being a teacher who accepts money and his curiosity of his searches in earth and heaven. Socrates’ response against the charges in general: meletus is guilty of dealing frivolously with serious matters, of irresponsibly bringing people into court, and of professing to be seriously concerned with things about none of which he has ever cared (24c. Socrates defends himself against the charges brought against him by his prosecutor meletus in two ways one way consists of a description of socrates’ motivation and method, which he hopes will explain to the jury why some people, including his prosecutors, dislike him.

The corruption charge, said socrates in his defense, was because by questioning people in public, he embarrassed them, and they, in turn, accused him of corrupting the youth of athens by the use of sophistry. That socrates is not guilty of the charges brought against him can be seen from the fact that he has not been trying to indoctrinate anyone he does not claim that his own views are perfect or that he has arrived at the final truth concerning the matter under consideration. Socrates made enemies, three of whom brought charges against him socrates was tried for his life in 399 bc, found guilty, and put to death by drinking hemlock (a herbal poison ) [1] the story of his trial and death is the subject of a tract by plato which is called the apologia. In the apology, socrates examines the charges brought against him by meletus and tries to prove that they are false the first charge brought against him is that he was corrupting the youth socrates responds to this by asking meletus in his opinion, how socrates was corrupting the youth.

I will begin at the beginning and ask what is the accusation which has given rise to the slander of me, and in fact, has encouraged meletus to proof this charge against me. Go here for more about socrates go here for more about plato go here for more about socrates' apology by plato it follows the english translation of the full text transcript of socrates' apology according to plato, delivered at athens, greece - 399 bc this is page 1 of 2 go to page 2 how you. Certainly excuse me if i spoke in that dialect and manner in which i had been brought up, so too saying that there is a man called socrates, a wise m an, a student of all th ings in the sky and below the earth, who makes the worse slander in which meletus trusted when he wrote out the charge against me what did they say when they. The apology powerpoint presentation, ppt - docslides- philosophy 21 fall, 2004 g j mattey socrates on trial socrates was defending himself against two charges brought forth by meletus corruption of the youth of athens by turning them against religion id: 165488.

An open-minded and conscientious member of the jury could therefore have come to the conclusion that socrates posed a significant threat to the city and should be found guilty of the charges against him in a way, socrates did fail to acknowledge the gods recognized by the city, he did introduce new. The last days of socrates is a book on the philosophical discussions between socrates and plato it is divided into four sections the “euthyphro” tells of the charges laid out against socrates in the “phaedo” the last days and death of socrates are told character analysis socrates – a seventy year old man about to be. Socrates states that the charge of corruption of the youth is a stock charge against all philosophers the charge may well be common against sophists, but such a defense is irrelevant to socrates' situation.

An analysis of the charges against socrates brought upon him by a man meletus

The charges against socrates were brought upon him by a man names meletus meletus was a young man that socrates did not know very well these charges brought on by meletus caused the indictment of socrates. In plato’s apology, the charges brought against socrates show the main reasons for his unpopularity in athens: socrates is guilty of criminal meddling, in that he inquires into things below the earth and in the sky, and makes the weaker argument defeat the stronger, and teaches others to follow his example. During the first three hours of the trial of socrates, meletus and the other two accusers each made speeches to the jury making the case for the guilt of socrates the motivation for meletus to bring charges against socrates is a matter of debate. The apology of socrates is not about saying sorry but it is one of the great speeches in the history of philosophy the greek philosopher defends himself against his accusers and ultimately.

  • Meletus would serve as the prosecutor and present his charges at the trial and the evidence against the accused, socrates meletus was a conservative, something of a religious fanatic who had also brought charges against the orator, andocides.
  • It also talks about the charges that meletus has brought forth against socrates which is that he corrupted the young 2nd passage- in this passage, socrates uses god as his main root of explanation he states how god has ordered him to do what he is doing and that he must do so, and if he is accused for corrupting the youth, then they would.
  • At this point, socrates turns to meletus, who, he says, has frivolously brought these charges against him not only that, but he has been irresponsible in bringing together the jury however, worst of all is that he does not truly care about the things he accuses socrates of doing.

Three of the major charges that were brought against socrates include, questioning heaven and earth, teaching people to make a weaker argument appear stronger, and corrupting the youth as we dive into the text, socrates will explain that many people feel wronged or put down by him, and this is why these charges are brought against him. In feeling as though he has proven to the jury that this charge is false, that he does not corrupt the young, socrates tells the jury why he thinks meletus really has brought him into court he feels as though meletus just doesnвђ™t like him and that bringing him into court on these charges is just a way to get ride of him. Socrates response to the accusation of him corrupting the youth by first reminding them of the accusation and in order to defend himself against these charges, he called up meletos, who was the principal accuser, to the stance and began to question him. Having addressed the earlier accusers of those who have generated and spread the kind of reputation he has, socrates now moves to the real charges against him at the moment, and one of his real accusers, meletus.

An analysis of the charges against socrates brought upon him by a man meletus
Rated 5/5 based on 30 review

2018.